The Sundarban 
overlays-textures/Shutterstock
An thrilling unusual ask titled “Soot Planets instead of Water Worlds“, by Jie Li and colleagues, printed in August 2025, challenges prevailing assumptions in regards to the nature of many low-density exoplanets. These planets that had been interpreted as water worlds (quiet of rock and necessary water ice) would possibly perchance presumably furthermore as a substitute owe their low densities to gargantuan portions of refractory carbon, furthermore called soot in astrophysics.
In the ask’s model, planets forming beyond the so-called “soot-line” in the protoplanetary disc can salvage a huge quantity of natural carbon in solid assemble, but water ice remains unstable. This unusual classification challenges lengthy-standing assumptions in regards to the frequency and composition of planets just like the oceanic world chanced on 100 lightyears from Earth. That near that the massive majority of the sub-Neptune and mini-Neptune planets will be misclassified below easy rock and water items. Beyond their compositional implications, soot planets furthermore elevate unusual questions about atmospheric chemistry, internal dynamics, and even habitability. If carbon-bearing solids are extra customary than frigid volatiles, the universe would possibly perchance presumably furthermore host extra darkish, natural-rich worlds than we imagined.
Soot planets and their formation
Soot planets are a newly proposed class of exoplanets made largely of refractory natural carbon, a tar-like material that incorporates carbon, hydrogen, oxygen, and nitrogen, in most cases shortened by scientists to CHON. This soot is no longer honest just like the shadowy residue left by fire on Earth, but a posh mix of carbon compounds that would possibly perchance presumably stay on mighty elevated temperatures than water ice. Because of that, soot can stay solid in regions of space where ice would favor a flash soften and evaporate.
The postulate at the relieve of the soot planets originates from the discovery that many exoplanets labeled as water worlds would possibly perchance presumably furthermore in actuality be quiet of rock mixed with these solid carbon materials. All the method in which through planet formation, varied varieties of solids exist in varied temperature zones of a younger superstar’s disk. Shut to the superstar, all the pieces is too hot, and materials vaporize. Extra out, they condense into solids. The soot line marks the space where CHON materials first change into actual and would possibly perchance presumably stick together, around 500 Okay (about 230 °C). Even additional out lies the snow line, shut to 150 Okay (-120 °C), where water can freeze.
Planets that assemble between these two boundaries bring together silicate rock and soot, but slight water ice. Modeling by Li and colleagues reveals that such planets would appear moral as light as water worlds when measured by telescopes. This near that soot planets would possibly perchance presumably with out peril be mistaken for water ice ones.
Internal these soot planets, heat and stress would possibly perchance presumably flip the soot into graphite, and even diamond, changing how they behavior heat and evolve over time. In aquire, soot planets are worlds constructed on carbon in preference to water. They’re darkish, dense, and chemically rich, formed by the same ingredients imprint in comets and interstellar mud.
Soot planets will be habitable
Pitris/Getty Pictures
If soot planets assemble efficiently in the warmer regions of a protoplanetary disk, they’ll be extra necessary than water worlds. The materials that originate them, carbon-rich and CHON compounds, are actual and in vogue in the protoplanetary disk — though planet-forming disks even possess pretty quite loads of water in them. Observations of comets and meteorites in our possess photo voltaic machine imprint that these carbon-based mostly solids can originate up a gargantuan part of the readily accessible constructing material, most ceaselessly as mighty as 40%. Since soot can stay on elevated temperatures than ice, the placement where soot planets can assemble is method elevated and lies closer to their stars than the placement where water worlds can assemble.
Astronomers possess observed that many low-density exoplanets chanced on by missions equivalent to Kepler or TESS will be outlined by both a combination of rock and water or a combination of rock and soot. Because both mixtures would give planets similar sizes and loads, soot worlds will be hiding in undeniable watch among the planets already is known as water worlds. This overlap makes it complicated to know what these planets are in actuality product of with out extra detailed observations of their ambiance and composition.
As for habitability, soot planets would fresh foremost challenges, but they’ll no longer be completely uninteresting. Their carbon-rich mantles would possibly perchance presumably open gases like methane, hydrogen, and ammonia, forming thick, hazy atmospheres. These gases would possibly perchance presumably entice heat from stars, presumably allowing temperate surfaces or subsurfaces to exist. Alternatively, with slight water and restricted geological recycling, the predict of what a actual, habitable climate appears to be like like would be pretty varied. If life ever emerged on a soot planet, with pretty slight native pockets of liquid, scientists don’t appear to be in actuality determined what that planet would gape like. Such worlds would be unfamiliar, but they would perhaps presumably furthermore aloof abet the basic to working out life’s chemical chances beyond Earth.
